What Does It Mean When AM Best Rates an Insurance Company?

What Does It Mean When AM Best Rates an Insurance Company?

You can frequently find AM Best ratings displayed on the company webpage of an insurance provider, and you might see these ratings cited in evaluations of auto and home insurance policies. But what exactly does it mean when AM Best rates an insurance company? Should you make your decision about where to buy your insurance coverage based on what they say? We will investigate the nature of these ratings, the organization that is responsible for them, and whether or not you should place your faith in them.

Key Takeaways

  • The credit ratings assigned by AM Best provide information regarding the soundness of an insurance provider’s finances.
  • During the rating process, consideration is given to a number of aspects, including an insurance company’s business profile, balance sheet, and operating performance, as well as how the company fares compared to its rivals.
  • Insurance companies take the ratings given to them by AM Best very seriously because they know that their existing customers, potential customers, and investors use these ratings to evaluate the companies’ ability to pay claims.

What Kind of AM Rating Is Ideal?

Since its founding in 1899, AM Best has been providing policyholders with a method for determining the full financial standing of various insurance companies. In order to assist individuals in determining the creditworthiness of an insurer, the agency provides in-depth financial analysis reports. It evaluates various insurance companies based on a single letter grade after compiling extensive information about each of the companies. This document serves as a sort of report card for your insurance company. You can put this information to use to assist you in coming to an informed decision regarding the purchase of insurance to meet your requirements.

AM Best assigns ratings to insurance companies in categories such as:

  • Captive insurance
  • Insurance for life and/or annuities
  • Insurance for medical care
  • Property and casualty insurance, which includes coverage for your home and vehicle
  • Reinsurance Securities Linked to Insurance Companies
  • Guarantees on both the title and the mortgage

The Process Behind the AM Best Insurance Ratings

AM Best is distinct from other rating agencies in that it focuses solely on the business of providing ratings for the insurance industry. The process of rating an insurance company considers several factors, including the company’s business profile, balance sheet, and operating performance, as well as how the company compares to its rivals.

AM Best publishes four distinct “Best Credit Ratings,” and each one evaluates a distinct facet of a company’s financial strength and capacity to meet its ongoing financial obligations. These ratings are a good benchmark of how successfully a company might weather difficult economic conditions and other financial challenges, so it is important to pay attention to them.

Explaining the Ratings of Insurance Companies

The “Best’s Financial Strength Rating” is considered to be one of the “Best Credit Ratings.” It provides a succinct summary of the objective assessment that AM Best has made concerning the financial health of an insurance company and its ability to meet its insurance obligations, such as paying out claims. You will come across one of the following FSRs when you check AM Best’s insurance ratings to authenticate the financial health of an insurance provider:

Rating Categories

Rating Symbols


A+, A++


A, A-


B+, B++


B, B-


C+, C++


C, C-



The scores that are used to represent the various rating categories are called rating symbols. They include positive and negative ratings, which Best refers to as “rating notches,” to indicate minor financial strength variations within each category. Take, for instance, the rating of “Superior” assigned by AM Best to two different insurance companies. This indicates that the agency believes both companies have a superior ability to meet their financial obligations; however, one insurer may receive an A+, while the other company may be deemed slightly more impressive and earn an A++.

Members who are registered with AM Best are eligible to receive complimentary access to Best’s Credit Ratings as well as company information. The registration process is also completely free; all we require is your name, email address, and password. You can contact the customer support team at AM Best by calling 908-439-2200 extension 5742 if you have any questions or require assistance.

What Does it Mean for Insurance Companies to Have an AM Best Rating?

The rating information that AM Best issues is taken very seriously by insurance companies because these companies are aware that both current and potential customers, as well as investors, use these ratings to evaluate a company’s financial strength. Companies that are financially secure and have positive outlooks inspire confidence not only in policyholders and investors but also in shareholders and employees; all of these stakeholders play an important role in an insurer’s expansion, profitability, and long-term stability.

AM Best ratings are typically updated once a year, in addition to other times when significant events may have an impact on those ratings. Ratings are susceptible to change depending on factors such as an organization’s:

  • The state of the company’s finances, including underwriting, credit, market risks, and other aspects.
  • Comparison to other businesses in the same industry, as well as to proprietary benchmarks and industry standards.
  • They may also consider operations plans, risk tolerance, backing from a parent company or affiliates, management, and other factors.

An AM Best rating is essential for a number of reasons, one of which is that it represents the independent opinion of AM Best regarding how well it believes the insurance company will perform in the not too distant future. The forecast may be optimistic, pessimistic, or merely unchanged.

AM Best Ratings Have Been Called Into Question

Despite having a generally good track record, AM Best, along with other rating agencies (such as Fitch, Moody’s, and Standard & Poor’s), came under heavy criticism during the financial crisis in 2008 for providing overly positive assessments of the insurance holding company American International Group (AIG). The continued operation of dozens of insurance companies that AIG owned was put in jeopardy as a direct result of the enormous losses that occurred at AIG Financial Products, the company’s subsidiary that is involved in trading derivatives. AM Best and other rating agencies were taken aback and criticized for failing to realize how risky AIG’s trading operations were sooner, which caught everyone off guard. AM Best’s decision to downgrade the company’s financial strength rating from A++ to A+ was in direct response to this news. The federal government saved AIG at the cost of $182 billion, which was paid back by the time February 2013 came to a close.

Publications Dealing With Insurance News

AM Best is the publisher of a number of insurance news products, one of which is called Best’s Insurance News & Analysis, which offers insurance news from around the world. BestDay is an online news digest, and Bestweek is a weekly newsletter focusing on the insurance industry. Both are included. In addition, there is AMBestAudio, BestWeek Live, which is a weekly online video program; Best’s Review, which is a monthly magazine; AMBestTV, which is a free streaming video service; AM Best Webinars, which are events presented by industry leaders; and (podcast service).

Best Analytical Products from AM Best

Besides rating services and insurance news publications, AM Best gives its members access to a vast collection of analytical products, which makes it possible to conduct an in-depth investigation of the insurance sector. These products include the following:

  • Through Best’s Insurance Reports, users have access to in-depth analytical reports on thousands of insurance companies, reinsurers, and other groups located all over the United States of America, Canada, and the rest of the world.
  • Credit reports for individual insurers that contain financial analysis, in-depth commentary, and a variety of other information are referred to as Best’s Credit Reports. You can purchase individual Best’s Credit Reports or purchase them as part of a collection.
  • The Best Library Center is located at: The AM Best Library Center is a helpful online resource available to public and academic libraries. One can use it to research information related to insurance.
  • Best’s Capital Adequacy Ratio Model—P/C, US: An application for desktop computers that provides access to the model that AM Best utilizes in the process of calculating Capital Adequacy Ratio scores for single and group insurance companies operating in the property and casualty sectors in the United States.
  • Best’s Capital Adequacy Ratio Model—Universal: A tool that is based on Excel and gives you access to the same model that is used by AM Best to calculate the Capital Adequacy Ratio scores for single and group insurance companies in the life and non-life sectors in areas outside of the United States and Canada. This model is used to determine the scores for single and group insurance companies in areas outside of the United States and Canada.

On the Product Directory page of AM Best’s website, one can find a list of all of the company’s resources, reports, programs, and other offerings.

AM Best Ratings for Insurance –– the bottom line

AM Best is an insurance rating agency that has been in business for a very long time. In spite of the fact that it has made errors in the past, the meticulous analysis of an insurer’s financial strength can assist prospective customers and investors in making well-informed decisions about which insurer to select. AM Best’s evaluation of an insurance provider’s ability to pay claims and meet its other financial obligations is generally reliable for both customers and policyholders.

Having said that, AM Best is one of the five independent agencies that rate the financial strength of an insurance company. The other four agencies are Moody’s, Fitch, Kroll Bond Rating Agency (KBRA), and Standard & Poor’s. Because these rating agencies do not always agree in their assessments of a particular insurer, it is essential to consider ratings from at least two agencies before deciding which insurance policy to purchase. It would be best if you did this in addition to comparing the coverage offered by various insurance companies. You will be able to locate the insurance provider that is the most suitable for your requirements in this way.

Leave a Reply