Which device is better: the Garmin Vivosmart 3 or the Fitbit Alta HR?

The Fitbit Alta HR and the Vivosmart 3 are the only new fitness trackers that have been released so far in 2017 by Fitbit and Garmin, respectively. Because of this, according to their criteria, the first five months of the year got off to a poor start. It’s possible that the second half will be more entertaining than the first.

Both of these wearables integrate changes that were brought about by evolution rather than evolution itself. It might be argued that the Alta HR and the Vivosmart 3 are now among the greatest solutions available for the typical person who is looking for a reliable activity tracker that can be worn at all times. They are user-friendly, dependable, and offer excellent critical statistics all in one package.

If you are having trouble choosing between the two options, read on to find out how they compare to one another.

The Alta HR’s design has not changed all that much since the ultra-slim and fashionable version that was released the previous year. The Garmin Vivosmart 3 is an alternative to the Alta HR. Fitbit’s newest wearable is part of the company’s goal to create devices that give the impression of being stylish accessories rather than nerdy gadgets.

On the other hand, the Vivosmart 3 has undergone an extensive amount of redesign. It now has a more streamlined appearance and a brand new sort of display that, when it is not in use, merges in with the band itself.

On the Vivosmart 3, you will find a touchscreen display that is OLED, black and white, and has 64 x 128 pixels. The OLED panel that Fitbit has chosen to use has a resolution of 128 by 36 pixels, is somewhat curved, and is touch-screen enabled. Both are quite convenient for getting a fast look at your statistics, but there will be instances when reading them will be challenging for you. This is especially true with regard to the Alta HR, which presently possesses a very compact display.

Which device is better: the Garmin Vivosmart 3 or the Fitbit Alta HR?

By default, both trackers are turned off, and they only become active when you raise your wrist or tap on the screen. This is done in order to make the battery last longer. On both the Alta HR and the Vivosmart 3, there are no physical buttons; instead, navigation is accomplished by repeatedly tapping on the touch screen. This frees you from having to rely solely on your smartphone to monitor your progress as thoroughly as before.

The bands on the trackers are made of rubber, and they come equipped with clasp mechanisms resembling those seen on normal watches. They are simple to put on and take off. The Alta HR comes with a variety of interchangeable bands, giving you the ability to pick one that complements your individual sense of style. To put on or remove the bands, you need to press a button. Because there are few customization choices available for Garmin wearable, your only choice is between two colors: black or purple. Neither of these colors can be changed.

Despite the fact that it is touted as being suitable for both men and women, the Alta HR is definitely going to be most popular among women who are interested in fitness. Because of the simplicity of its design, it would go well with other jewelry, such as a bracelet or even a watch. On the other hand, the design of the Vivosmart 3 leans considerably more toward being appropriate for either a man or a woman.

There is not much of a difference between the two behind the hood. Both detect your heart rate optically and come equipped with a three-axis accelerometer and vibration motor. On the Vivosmart 3, you will also discover an altimeter that can count the number of floors

It is remarkable that Alta HR was able to monitor the user’s heart rate around the clock with such a small wearable device. Fitbit was able to accomplish this through the creation of a one-of-a-kind chip that decreased the required size as well as the number of components. Other sensors are exactly the same as they were in the Alta from the previous year.

Garmin has removed the built-in GPS from the Vivosmart HR+ but has added some more advanced fitness tracking options such as VO2 max and fitness age, stress tracking throughout the day, and the ability to count reps and sets while working out in the gym.

Which is better, the Garmin Vivosmart 3 or the Alta HR? Battery life and resistance to water

The battery life of the Vivosmart 3 is approximately 5 days, but this can vary based on how it is used, the settings, and other factors. Even with the addition of a heart rate monitor, the Alta HR is able to maintain its functionality for up to a week, which is rather remarkable. When Apple finally releases its Series 3 watch later this year, it will undoubtedly have something to compete with thanks to this.

Since the Alta HR is not waterproof, let’s keep our fingers crossed that Fitbit will add this feature to the future edition. It is merely classified as “sweat, rain, and splash proof,” just like the majority of Fitbit’s other gadgets. This indicates that you shouldn’t plan on going swimming, despite the fact that it may be OK to go jogging in the rain.

Because it is water-resistant to a depth of 50 meters, the AD Vivosmart 3 can be worn in the shower or while swimming. The device will automatically track swimming exercises, but the data it records will be limited to the basics. The tracker is designed to be waterproof. However, it does not have a mode that works properly while swimming. Let’s keep our fingers crossed that this is something that can be fixed with a future firmware update.

Compare the features of the Garmin Vivosmart 3 and the Alta HR

Because the Alta now also monitors your heart rate, you will find all of the most important information on each of its companion wearables. This implies that the trackers will keep track of your steps, distance traveled, active minutes, calories burned, and sleep throughout the day and night. Both of these options are viable options if what you need is a tool that can monitor your activity levels on a fundamental level.

Move reminders can also be found in the Vivosmart 3 and Alta HR, both of which do an excellent job of getting you off the couch. Because there is automated activity recognition, you will gain credit even if you neglect to log an exercise because it will be recognised automatically. You can go for a vigorous run, a mild jog, or even just a simple walk, and when you’re finished, the app will have all of the data from your workout saved for you.

They also include intelligent notifications, which allow you to remain connected even when you are on the move. You will get information on incoming calls, texts, and notifications from your calendar. The limited size of the screen on the Alta HR, on the other hand, makes this feature less useful. To check notifications on one or both of your devices, you will probably discover that you are reaching for your smartphone the majority of the time.

Because the ability to recognise sleep occurs automatically, there is no need to inform your electronic gadget that you intend to take a nap. The most recent update to the Fitbit app gives users more granular statistics. This contains estimates of how long you spend in each stage of sleep each night, including light, deep, and REM sleep. The software also analyses the statistics and provides recommendations on how you might increase the amount of time you spend sleeping. The statistics provided by Garmin are a little less sophisticated. You are provided with information regarding deep sleep, light sleep, and your average awake time.

Monitoring of your heart rate occurs throughout the day, in addition to monitoring your ticker over the course of a particular workout. On the screen, you can see your current heart rate, as well as your resting heart rate, and your heart rate zones while you are working out. It is important to note that while the readings from both trackers will be comparable when it comes to your heart rate at rest, the numbers will not be as accurate when measuring your heart rate during high-intensity activities. A chest strap is still the best technique to monitor your heart rate during exercise if you take your workouts very seriously.

Which device is better: the Garmin Vivosmart 3 or the Fitbit Alta HR?

The Vivosmart 3 has various features that the Alta HR tracker does not have, despite the fact that the Alta HR has a greater number of features overall than its predecessor. When it comes to tallying floors, we have already discussed the altimeter. Another one of these is a feature that monitors your stress levels.

AD Garmin has placed a greater emphasis on your health by analyzing the fluctuation of your heart rate in order to obtain a sense of how you are feeling mentally. On the device, your present stress level will be indicated, while the app on your smartphone will provide you with access to a longer timeframe. You will be provided with peaceful mindfulness experiences by way of deep-breathing exercises, something that you will also find on the Charge 2, but not on the Alta HR. These experiences will help you become worry-free.

The counting of reps for strength training is a fairly innovative function. This is a hybrid method that involves manually marking activities and automatically tallying the number of repetitions. Graphs of your heart rate are captured and shown by the Vivosmart 3 while you are working out with it.

It’s possible that the VO2 max feature is more helpful. This effectively represents a new method for tracking your total fitness over the course of time. The Garmin device will not only provide you with an estimate of your VO2 max, but it will also provide your “fitness age.” Before this, VO2 max could only be found on the most high-end models of Garmin’s sports watches.

The app requires either the Garmin Vivosmart 3 or the Alta HR

Because both trackers distribute a substantial amount of data, the software component is an extremely significant part of the whole equation. In this case, there is a significant gap between the two.

In the same way that Garmin does, Fitbit equips all of its trackers with the same app. The software is incredibly user-friendly, with everything being well-organized and easy to understand. The most relevant metrics will be displayed on the main page, and tapping on a tile will transport you to a screen with additional information. You may access the dashboard screen, challenges, friends, and account data via tabs that are located along the bottom of the page.

Which device is better: the Garmin Vivosmart 3 or the Fitbit Alta HR?

The Garmin Connect app is quite extensive, but it is not even close to being as user-friendly and straightforward as In comparison to Fitbit, there is a broader breadth of information available, but the learning curve is significantly steeper. There is a good chance that the information you are seeking already exists, but, in many cases, locating this information can be an extremely challenging endeavor.

The bottom line on the Garmin Vivosmart 3 vs. the Alta HR:

In many ways, the new Fitbit and Garmin fitness trackers are similar to their predecessors.There is no revolutionary new technology being introduced; instead, corporations are refining their existing products to achieve slightly better results.

The Vivosmart 3 has a VO2 max, an altimeter, strength training, all-day stress tracking, and water resistance, making it the device with the greatest number of features overall. It generates data that is reasonably accurate and has a lot of features hidden away beneath the hood.

However, where Fitbit really shines is in the whole user experience that it provides. It has one of the most user-friendly interfaces available, making it one of the greatest apps currently available. The Alta HR has the distinction of being the more svelte of the two, but this comes at the expense of a much reduced amount of screen space.

Which device is better: the Garmin Vivosmart 3 or the Fitbit Alta HR?

These are trackers designed for the average person who wants a reliable activity device that works around the clock. and both have a lot of potential in this regard.

It is a no-brainer if you are truly serious about increasing your fitness or if you are seeking a way to maximize the return on your investment. It is very evident that the Vivosmart 3, which can be purchased for a price that is comparable to but somewhat lower than that of the Alta HR, is the product to purchase. If, on the other hand, you want something that is less obvious and more attractive to the eye, the Alta HR, with its streamlined appearance, is an excellent option to consider.

Leave a Reply