Is It Possible That Your Robotic Advisor Will Give You Bad Advice?

Is It Possible That Your Robotic Advisor Will Give You Bad Advice?

Robo-advisors have been very successful in encouraging new investors to test the waters of the stock market by providing low-cost and automated investment options. Using a robo-advisor will result in the creation of a portfolio that is tailored to your specific requirements. In addition, you have an algorithm guiding the ship. These algorithms were developed by financial specialists, and they are currently being handled by those same people. But it’s the computer that makes it possible for you to get professional advice at a much lower price.

When you decide to take the robotic route, keep the following in mind:

Key Takeaways

  • Robo-advisors are fiduciaries. However, customers should still make sure they are familiar with the operation of these algorithms.
  • Your comfort level with taking risks can be taken into account by a robo-advisor, but the results may not be accurate. Additionally, approaches differ from firm to firm.
  • Robo-advisors are unable to provide assistance in diversifying your portfolio for you. They simply provide a limited range of assets to choose from.
  • During times of market instability, robo-advisors might take action on their own. That being said, it is up to you to deviate from any predetermined behaviors.

What Do the Supporters and the Critics Think?

The model of the robo-advisor has a lot of positive aspects to it. Will Trout believes that it has made the market for investment management more accessible to more people. The paper, titled “Looking Under the Hood: Robo Advice, Portfolio Risk, and Regulation,” was written by Trout.

To attract the attention of a market advisor, it is no longer necessary to have $5 million; rather, all you need is $10,000 to be considered a millennial. But there is also the possibility that you may follow the herd and end up falling off a precipice. Trout says that investors should feel good about the performance of market-tracking instrument baskets as long as the markets keep going up.

Therefore, the question that needs to be asked is: what will take place if there is a severe enough market crisis and these pots lose their value? How do robo-advisors ensure that their customers are able to weather financial storms and keep them from making hasty decisions with their money? “

Cerulli Associates is a research organization that focuses on global asset management and distribution analytics. Scott Smith holds the position of director at Cerulli Associates. According to Smith, the problem isn’t so much that robo-advisors are wrong most of the time. But it’s possible that you’re not the right candidate for them.

“If there is a mismatch in expectations, it’s not that the robo did anything wrong—that investor shouldn’t have been with a robo in the first place,” says the author. “If there is a mismatch in expectations, it’s not that the robot did anything wrong.”

Are Automated Investment Advisors (robots) Really Trustworthy?

The question of whether or not robo-advisors can truly take on the role of fiduciaries is one that is being actively discussed. To put it another way, what are the legal obligations that they have to behave in the best interests of their clients?

There have traditionally been two primary benchmarks for the provision of financial advice:

A somewhat lax requirement: appropriateness. This means that different financial service providers, like brokers, can sell you a product that is just right for your needs.

A more stringent requirement is the provision of fiduciary counsel. Not only is the recommendation applicable, but following it will also be beneficial to you in the long run.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has accorded robo-advisors the status of fiduciaries. However, it also strongly encourages them to be open and honest about the process through which their algorithms generate suggestions. 

The majority of organizations will have you complete a questionnaire so that their robo-advisor can better understand your financial objectives. Additionally, the SEC emphasizes the significance of these surveys to ensure compliance with the fiduciary standard. They can be utilized by businesses as a tool for the purpose of better understanding their clientele. 

According to Sylvia Kwan, it is important for customers to “make an effort to grasp the investment philosophy or approach that’s underlying the hood.” Ellevest is a digital investment platform for women, and Kwan serves as the chief investment officer at Ellevest.

“Automation can be a brilliant technique in many different contexts; but, due to the fact that all robo-advisors are driven by an algorithm, and algorithms are built by people, the algorithm is a reflection of the company.”

How do automated advisors (Robo-Advisors) handle risk?

Do you intend to buy a car within the next five years? A home in ten years? Or are you considering the more distant future? Perhaps you are planning for your retirement as well as the schooling of your children.

You may get started in the same way regardless of what your objective is. First things first pinpoint both your end goal and your time frame. This is why your risk profile and strategy should be based, in part, on what you want to accomplish with your money and when you want to accomplish it. This will also assist you in responding to the questionnaire provided by your robot.

The vast majority of robo-advisors will take these requirements into consideration. The next step is for them to attempt to prod you into making the appropriate selections regarding asset allocation based on your requirements. However, not everyone does it in the same manner at all times.

“If you’re saving for your kid’s college, we’ll give you a recommendation. We call them risk tolerance bands, and you can deviate a few points up or down,” says Nick Holeman, a Certified Financial Planner working for Betterment. “If you’re saving for your own retirement, we won’t give you a recommendation.”

“If you want to take more of a risk and opt for 55 percent stock, despite our recommendation of 50 percent stock, that’s fine with us.” If you start to depart quite a little, say up to 80 percent, we will push back on you a little harder and say, “Hey, it looks like you’re taking on too much risk.” “Are you certain that this is something you still want to do?”

In 2008, Betterment made its debut on the market, operating only as a robo-advisor. Since then, it has expanded its range of services to include human advisors.

Should We Rely on Robo-Advisors Instead?

According to Trout, the limited selection of assets provided by robo-advisors, in general, is reason enough to make sure that you are not putting all of your eggs in the robo-basket. “You want to distribute your assets over all sorts of investments, not just the stocks and securities held by robo-advisors,” he says. “You don’t want to limit yourself to only stocks and securities.” “The diversification that is made available by robo-advisors is not particularly potent.”

Although robos provide you access to the entire stock market, you run the danger of having your money go down the drain. Even after accounting for rebalancing and tax-loss harvesting, this remains the case. That is why it is important to spread your investments over a variety of asset classes and types of investments. This includes keeping some of your wealth in cash, investing in real estate, and possibly trading commodities.

How do automated advisors, or robo-advisors, react when the market is volatile?

In 2016, Betterment put a halt to its business operations due to the instability caused by Brexit. This was done to stop its consumers from acting rashly with their financial resources and making rash decisions. Jon Stein, the Chief Executive Officer of Betterment, has said in public that this was a smart move.

The majority of the time, robos are self-driving automobiles. Nevertheless, you are able to take control of the vehicle at any time by grasping the steering wheel. By doing this, Betterment caused the airbags to go off, leaving their investors completely helpless.

Arielle Sobel, a representative for Betterment, said that the company’s communication might have been better. “We have full faith in it, and most of the feedback we’ve gotten from clients has been good.”

Perhaps. However, the manner in which various service providers respond to such circumstances will vary.

According to Holeman, the Chief Financial Planner, “the method we’ve taken is more reactive than proactive.” “For instance, if you were to log in during a Brexit, you would see a notification, but if you didn’t log in, you wouldn’t see it.”

When market conditions are volatile, certain advisors will contact their clients via mass email or phone. This could be true for human advisors just as easily as it may be true for robo-advisors. Some people don’t because they believe that this type of communication can backfire on them if some of their customers aren’t anxious to begin with.

It is also important to think about the many ways in which robo-advisors, such as Betterment, protect their clients against market fluctuations. The majority of robo advisors will automatically rebalance your portfolio and engage in tax-loss harvesting whenever the market experiences a downturn.

“These tactics allow you to transform negative market conditions into an opportunity to improve your portfolio. However, there is no way to avoid suffering losses, “says Holeman.

In these troubled times for the market, a robo might not be the best tool for you to use if you want to actively participate and give input.

How do robo-advisors grasp the big picture of your financial situation?

The level of customization of your portfolio will be determined by how well a robo-advisor learns about you and your willingness to take risks. For this reason, filling out its questionnaire is really crucial.

“There is less certainty that the account has been tailored for [your specific] interests and needs,” says Smith. “If you go through and fill out a five-question questionnaire, there is less certainty that you have done so.” It is imperative that we keep financial planning and portfolio management distinct. [Management of portfolios] is a component of planning, but it is only one of many components. “

Because of this, more and more leaders in the sector are starting to provide their clients with holistic services. Robo-advisor Path was initially presented by Wealthfront, for example. The Path is an automatic function that prompts users to consider several questions, including the following:

  • Do I only want my finances to be managed by someone else? 
  • Or do I also want the ability to discuss my financial situation?
  • Do I want an investment management tool? 
  • Or do I want a relationship with a financial planner in addition to an investment management tool?

Betterment did the same thing, bringing human guidance back into the mix, for the same reason. According to Sobel, “we also discovered that talking about money is a touchy subject.” “And if you want to put your money with a company that you can trust, the best way to do so is to communicate with a real person.”

If you don’t know who you are, the robot won’t be able to either.

Knowing who you are as an investor is the only way to successfully carry out what it is you want to do. When it comes to filling out the questionnaires, you need to be thoughtful and honest if you want to be able to exercise proactive control over what a robo-advisor does with your money.

“When going through their surveys, people really need to think about themselves and make sure they answer what they feel—not what they believe the robo or firm wants them to feel,” the author of the article said.

Instead of responding intellectually to the questions, try answering them emotionally instead. This may sound counterintuitive, but try it. Consider the following scenario: the market is experiencing a decline. One interpretation could be that you recognize it as a window of opportunity to make a purchase. But if the thought of the market going down makes your heart rate go up in a way that isn’t good for you, this is a problem that needs your attention.

Leave a Reply