Is It Possible That Your Robotic Advisor Will Give You Bad Advice?

Is It Possible That Your Robotic Advisor Will Give You Bad Advice?

Robo-advisors are frequently recommended as the best choice for novice investors. They are hailed as some of the most affordable choices that can target your precise requirements and risk tolerance with the precision of an Olympic archer.

They do have certain limits, though. If you’re considering using or have already begun using a robo-advisor, here’s what you need to know. Your future may not be sealed the way you believe it will be.

A Robo-Advisor is what?

Robo-advisors employ a digital trading and investing platform that is algorithm-driven. With little to no human assistance, they create financial portfolios depending on your objectives and risk tolerance. As you may expect, robo-advisors provide certain automatic functions like tax optimization and rebalancing. Here is a brief explanation of how a robo-advisor operates: You’ll fill out a brief survey so the robo-advisor “understands” your objectives and can figure out how to invest your money automatically. Your inquiries may occasionally be answered by human advisors, although it isn’t usually a feature or an option.

The robo-advisor’s algorithm creates an investment portfolio that precisely matches your time horizon and goals based on the information you submit. You can set up a robo-advisor to include contributions from your bank automatically. Last but not least, the robo-advisor manages your portfolio by implementing tax-loss harvesting through technology so you can offset capital gains and rebalance your portfolio.

Some Arguments Against Using a Robo-Advisor

Here are some reasons why you might want to consider other solutions even though everything sounds simple.

Reason 1: They might only provide a small selection of money resources

When compared to alternative solutions, robo-advisors frequently offer a lack of diversification. Robo-advisors may not provide you with the most diverse selection of asset classes, including cash, real estate, and commodities.

Reason 2: Their understanding of your financial situation is constrained.

Of course they do, then. They are machines.

The point is that everyone has unique needs that are quite complex. Furthermore, robo-advisors lack the human financial advisor’s individualized perspectives.

Consider a scenario in which your investment strategy has been successful for years. Then a wildfire starts to burn and devastates your property. Can a robo-advisor then advise you on what to do?


What happens if your child, who is typically healthy, develops cancer? Your financial situation can suddenly alter, necessitating a fundamentally different approach to investing. Robo-advisors cannot provide comprehensive planning guidance.

Reason 3: They won’t be stimulating to active investors

You won’t like robo-advisors if you’re not a passive investor. A robo-advisor won’t work for day traders unless they also choose to diversify their portfolio with long-term assets, which is a wise decision. Even so, you should probably open a brokerage account for your investments that enables you to actively trade and test out different trading methods.

Reason 4: Is that your robo-advisor just follows instructions

A robo-advisor is unable to persuade you. (Unless, of course, a human advisor component is offered.)

For illustration, suppose you say to a robo-advisor at the age of 24: “I’m not comfortable with risk” without realizing what it means. Your money’s inability to expand doesn’t matter to a robo-advisor. Your money will be invested in low-yield bonds, and it will thereafter close shop. It doesn’t matter whether your money increases slowly over the period of 20 years.

You might learn that you need to adjust your approach with the assistance of a human advisor. A human advisor might firmly state, “You’ll only make $22,000 on a $10,000 investment with this 2% bond return you’ve chosen, for instance. But suppose you raise your risk tolerance and instead receive 8% returns. Instead of $10,000, you’ll make nearly $215,000 from it.

A human advisor can visually explain the effects of your decisions over time.

Reason 5: Robo fees don’t always imply transparency

Robotic advisers do eliminate numerous expenses and middlemen, but they still make money off of their clients. Even when the investment doesn’t actually fit your needs, some robo advisors profit by investing your money in funds where they will make more money.

Fees for human advisors not your thing? We are aware. However…

Think you’d like to do it yourself rather than work with a financial expert to save money? We comprehend.

But consider this: Delaying hiring a financial counselor may end up costing you hundreds of thousands of dollars over the course of your lifetime. Consider hiring a human financial advisor to help manage your passive investments if you lack the time to do so. Your handling of money and investments may fall into the slush pile when you get overburdened with work, children, dog walking, and other responsibilities.

Remember that human counselors also advocate using passive investment techniques. Contrary to popular belief, they also support passively managed investments like exchange-traded funds (ETFs). And to be honest, why not look into it if the appropriate actively managed fund emerges that suits your short-term and perhaps even long-term financial goals (or perhaps takes into account your ESG preferences)?

Aside from the fundamentals like tax harvesting, human counselors can also offer more advanced tax techniques. Tax efficiency, particularly in bigger portfolios, can more than offset the additional costs associated with typical advising accounts.

How Do Robot Advisors Function?

An automated financial platform known as a robo-advisor employs computers to handle your finances. These firms frequently invest their clients’ money in mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs), with a concentration on the investments made in brokerage or tax-advantaged retirement accounts.

When you sign up for a robo-advisor, you might first be asked to complete a questionnaire about your goals, risk tolerance, age, income, assets, and age. The firm will then use this information to suggest possible investments for you. The robo-advisor may design a portfolio based on your responses or make recommendations from a list of portfolios based on your answers.

Additionally, robo-advisors handle a lot of the ongoing maintenance jobs like tax-loss harvesting and portfolio rebalancing that can boost your long-term returns or maintain the right level of risk. Additionally, robo-advisors may have lower account minimums and cost structures than conventional financial advisors because a large portion of the job is automated.

How Safe Are Robo-Advisors?

A robo-advisor might be just as secure as a real financial advisor, yet it’s wise to exercise caution when entrusting strangers with your money. But whether you invest on your own, with a financial counselor you hire, or with a robo-advisor, you always run the risk of losing money.

Although fintech firms like Betterment and Wealthfront helped robo-advisors gain popularity, some of the biggest traditional investment management firms, such Charles Schwab, Fidelity, and Vanguard, now offer these services.

However, this does not imply that every robo-advisor is the same. If you’re thinking about using one to manage your money, keep in mind the following information:

The Fiduciaries Are Robo-Advisors

A fiduciary is a person or business that is required by law to put the interests of their clients before their own. Robo-advisors are obligated to their clients under their fiduciary obligation as registered investment advisors.

Some robo-advisors have been charged and punished by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for violating their fiduciary duties. The same is valid for financial advisors, though. You can check the advisor’s public disclosure database to see their disciplinary record and licensing status prior to enrolling in or hiring them.

Robotic advisors cannot ensure profits

Robo-advisors frequently use inexpensive ETFs to build diverse portfolios. They might also employ current portfolio theory to identify a combination of investments that will yield the highest return relative to the level of risk you are willing to take. In an effort to keep your asset allocation, they might also adjust your portfolio.

That does not, however, imply that you can escape a loss during a broad slump or even certain that you will profit when the market is rising. Working with a financial advisor has the benefit of potentially allowing you to receive advice based on your personality and anxieties, something that robo-advisors cannot do.

Your investing questions won’t be addressed by robot advisors

Customer service and technical support personnel may be present on robo-advisors. You might not, however, be able to contact with a financial advisor who can respond to your investment-related queries, depending on the platform you select.

A hybrid model that provides you access to a financial planner is offered by certain robo-advisors. But consider the conditions for this access as well as how you’ll be able to contact them (by phone, email, or chat). If you wish to use a financial planner, you might need to have a minimum balance or pay a higher charge.

Different techniques are used by robo-advisors to select investments

Find out how your recommended portfolio is selected by the robo-advisor. The top selections are frequently narrowed down based on survey responses. However, certain systems could give you more customization possibilities for your portfolio. You could be able to add cryptocurrency assets, select a domestic or international focus, or open an account with a socially conscious investment fund, for instance.

There are various fee structures for robo-advisors

The robo-advisor often charges a fee based on the amount of money it is managing, and the fee may rise as your portfolio increases. Several exceptions exist, including Schwab Intelligent Portfolios. Although Schwab generates money by retaining a portion of your funds in cash at a bank that is linked with it and lending the deposits out to earn interest, this service offers a free robo-advisor service.

Investment management firms’ robo-advisors are permitted to make investments in their own funds. You may be required to pay separate fund management fees for these funds whether you invest on your own, with an advisor, or through a robo-advisor.

Robo-Advisors: Pros and Cons

You can determine whether the service is right for you by being aware of the advantages and disadvantages of a robo-advisor.


  • Less expensive: Robo-advisors typically charge less than human advisors. With robo-advisors, the charge can range from about 0.25% to 0.89% of the assets under management (AUM), or money you are investing. For investors with less than $1 million AUM, financial advisors may charge between 1% and 2% of the AUM.
  • Lower minimums: Some robo-advisors don’t have any minimum investment requirements, while others may have low minimum account requirements.
  • Simple to use If you are familiar with technology, the web-first approach might make robo-advising systems simple to use and comprehend.


  • Absence of potential human investment support: Although some robo-advisors offer the chance to speak with a financial advisor, this feature isn’t always available. Even then, the advisers might only be accessible to those who have higher-tiered subscriptions or accounts that meet specific minimum requirements.
  • Investment options that are restricted: Robo-advisors may compile a restricted list of portfolios and then select the one that best matches the investor’s needs. Many investors might find these portfolios to be a suitable fit, but not everyone may.
  • Narrow focus: While robo-advisors may assist you in building a portfolio for a particular objective, they do not produce financial plans that consider all of your objectives and investments.

At what point should you pick a robot advisor?

If you want to start investing but don’t want to pick or manage your investments yourself, a robo-advisor can be a smart choice. The services are frequently significantly less expensive and simpler to use than traditional consultants, and they can give you a largely hands-off experience.

A lot of robo-advisors also provide tax-favored retirement accounts, including IRAs. Tax-loss harvesting—the deliberate selling and buying of investments to realize capital losses—may also be available in non-retirement accounts, which might assist reduce your annual tax burden.

However, seeing a financial counselor may be a preferable alternative if you frequently need specialized guidance or have numerous particular issues. If you have a complicated financial position, such as several different investment accounts, trust funds, and retirement accounts, or if you have a lot of assets and would benefit from a more specialized approach, seeing a financial counselor may also be a smart choice.

If you need a financial plan or have a query but don’t want to pay for continuous investment management, you can discover financial experts who bill by the hour or project.

Make Smart Moves; Your Chances Are Limited

You don’t want to misjudge the situation. You only have one possible financial future. You only have one lifetime to make the decisions you want to make, kind of like picking a career. You can always modify your job path, but starting later or making a lot of different decisions along the road can have a negative financial impact.

Based on your needs, decide what is best for you. It’s acceptable if you require assistance from a human advisor. In the long run, it might even greatly improve your financial situation. In the long run, paying fees may be a smart trade-off for excellent results.

Leave a Reply